Ponzetti's Pizza

Seasonal local, first timer and was hoping this would be a go-to place. Ordered a medium cheese pizza for carryout, $18. Very expensive for what I got. Pizza was ready fast but the pizza is kept at the bar (vs. on an oven or heater) so by the time I was able to pay and by the time I got it home it was not hot. It was thin crispy crust but didn't have a lot of cheese. I've had better frozen pizzas. Also, it would be helpful to list prices on your website.

Sat in for a beer awaiting an order. Nice spot, looks more like a locals watering hole. The bartender, Jessica very delightful and friendly.

Not worth it honestly. I haven’t had a flavorless pizza in a long time, no seasoning, cheap ingredients and the phone never gets answered. We ordered a medium pepperoni and cheese, medium ham and cheese and a large works. The pepperoni and cheese was bland, sauce was too mild, cheese was thick but cheap. The ham and cheese had small slivers of ham, probably the equivalent of two slices of deli meat ham, again with the cheese. The works pizza had canned mushrooms (gross), canned peppers( ok) and canned olives (eh). The only meat I could find was some pepperoni and a few stragglers of sausage. The sauce was flavorless and again the cheese tasted like plastic. If you just want a frozen pizza or something like dominos, that’s fine, but for $70.00 I would expect something more flavorful.