Catch 54

38931 Madison Ave, Selbyville, DE 19975
(302) 436-8600
Open Now 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Sunday 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Monday 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Tuesday 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Wednesday 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Thursday 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Friday 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Saturday 12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
View Menu
Type: American, Beach Food, Seafood
Enjoy some of the best waterfront views on Delmarva while experiencing fresh Atlantic cuisine at Catch 54 by widely acclaimed chef Matt Haley.
 
Our newly built, two-story restaurant highlights the picturesque setting of Fenwick Island while providing a taste of coastal Delaware in a lively, casual atmosphere. Dine on locally caught seafood, steaks and more or enjoy a cocktail or bottle of wine at our expansive main or marina bars.
 
Catch 54 is located in Fenwick Island on Route 54, with both indoor and outdoor dining overlooking the waters of the Cove. 
 
Our pleasant, personable staff will ensure that you and your family enjoy your meal from start to finish. Come see why diners across the region eagerly look forward to their visits to Catch 54.
 
We're sorry, but we do not accept reservations.
Catch 54

Recent Reviews

Catch 54
Ginger J : 5 on 11/29/2024 7:29 pm
This place is awesome I would make one tiny suggestion to get a bread warmer when the bread hits the table and it's cold not great. The food was delicious and staff was fantastic. Drinks are awesome
Definitely will be back .
5 5
Catch 54
Tommy Mallory : 5 on 8/19/2024 12:09 am
There is plenty of nearby parking, friendly hostesses assisted with our choice of dining room or happy hour upstairs venue. We chose the dining room with comfortable booths and a great atmosphere. Our server promptly arrived, and we placed our drink order as well as their delicious appetizers. Compliments to the kitchen as our appetizers arrived moments before our drinks. We decided on our dinner selection some suggestions made by our server. Our drinks were refilled without asking, and our glasses never ran dry. The appetizer selection was delicious and enjoyed by everyone. The kitchen chef deserves a standing ovation and applause. Each entrée was a carnival of flavors with a touch of genius. Great presentation followed by award worthy deserts. We found exceptional world-class customer service and a great evening with friends. Thanks for the memories.
5 5
Catch 54
Niluksha Wickramaarachchi : 5 on 9/10/2024 2:44 am
This waterfront restaurant offers stunning views of the bay. We started with crab deviled eggs, crab dip, and cream of crab soup as appetizers. For our entrées, we had scallop fried rice, surf and turf, and lobster Alfredo—all of which were absolutely delicious. We also tried the crab bomb (crab cake) as a side, but it was just average. For dessert, we enjoyed a chocolate sundae and trifle, both of which were good.

We initially tried to make reservations online, but it didn’t work. When we called the restaurant, they informed us that they don’t take reservations. We joined the wait line at the restaurant and managed to get a table within 30 minutes, even during the busy Labor Day weekend.

Overall, we enjoyed our dinner and recommend this place if you are looking for a good seafood restaurant in the Fenwick Island, DE area.
5 5
Catch 54