Island Creamery

I had been to their Chincoteague location a long time ago, and I was thrilled to find out it's a small chain! I had their peanut butter cup and Snickers cheesecake. I've also had their Bourbon Caramel Crunch. All of them taste like genuine, homemade ice cream. If there's an Island Creamery out of your way, it's worth traveling for good quality ice cream!

We were in town for my sons baseball tournament. We had just finished fishing and were heading back to the hotel as it was getting late and I saw this place and was thinking how good ice cream sounded. It did not disappoint. Their homemade waffle cones are amazing. My son has a tree nut and peanut allergy and they made sure to take extra precaution (though they dont have separate "allergy safe" blenders and they have signs notifying customers of this) but just ice cream scoops/sundaes they take extra precaution and grabbed my sons from the back. I got coconut ice cream in a waffle cone, my son got mud marsh? (Something like that) in a waffle cone, and my boyfriend got some peanut butter sundae. They were all amazing and if we're ever in town again, I would absolutely come back.

First time visit. Very good ice cream. Compares to Lickety Splits in Seaford. Give them a try also. We got the Oreo and a Cherry Vanilla. Full of cookies and full of big sweet 🍒 Cherries . A lot of choices and free samples. All the flavors look good.