Fenwick Inn

In the past, we had a bad experience here but after 12 years, we decided to try again since they are pet friendly.
Maintaining a clean space when you are pet friendly is hard. But on night number 2 of our 4 night stay, a PERSON defecated in an elevator. This trail of feces went all the way down our hallway. We alerted the front desk but they did nothing until we complained that after a few hours, it was still all over our hallway. No way was it a dog. That is a dangerous situation and it should have been cleaned up right away.
Room was clean and had no pet odor. Pool was cold but the hot tub was nice. It's in a good location if you like quiet, sort of away from all the traffic of the inlet.
They will hit you with an additional $10 per night "resort fee". So it was actually an extra $40 over the advertised price (pet fee is an additional $30 per night plus another additional $10 in taxes. So technically $50/per night over advertised price) The room simply wasn't worth that much, especially in off season. I don't think we will be back.

We decided to stay here another year. I truly was impressed the first time I stayed. This year the room was not as clean as last year. Although it was nice I felt last year was much nicer. The check in wasn't as wonderful as last either. I do have to mention the hotel is very nice. I guess I expected the same quality and cleanliness as the first time staying. I would stay again

I stayed at the Fenwick Inn with my friend, her daughter and my Shepherd on a Sunday in September during bike week last month. 2024.
We had an early dinner and were in our room watching movies and went to bed very early.
I received 2 calls on my cell and a call to our room to “shut my dog up”. She was sleeping on my bed and we were all asleep. I did hear a small dog through the wall next door whimpering and crying for a long time.
At 12:40 am a Fenwick Inn employee flung open our door yelling at us to shut our dog up! I was horrified and furious.
I followed her downstairs asking her what the hell she thought she was doing. We were all asleep! No one is allowed to break into our room! We had a child in the room too.
She was mistaken about which room the dog was barking in.
I FINALLY got an email response a day or two ago. ( have been waiting for almost a month).
No one has returned phone calls, I have left messages and also emails.
The response I finally got was the employee thought the room was empty and went in to get a pillow. She called the room to yell at us! She 100% knew the room was occupied!
I emailed back that she is lying and demand some kind of proper apology, punishment for the employee and some compensation for this inexcusable behavior. I am still waiting.
Ridiculous way to run a hotel. I am very disappointed and will NOT be returning! No response from anyone!