TOAST

Don’t be deterred by their order website. I didn’t want to come here because it looked like a pizza shop with pasta. So glad I came though. Amazing deck and views from almost anywhere inside too. Lasagna was delicious. Friendly staff. Got the 2 for $32 special and it was worth it!

After a long day with friends etc…we had plans to call another good friend and meet up! We were pooped out and just decided to order carry out! It was a Saturday and very busy however someone did take our phone order and he was very nice!
We ordered a large pizza with pepperoni! It’s very good for never having had their pizza before. My husband picked up the pizza and asked for some peppers ….no one was able to even assist in getting any for him.
We will certainly return next trip and enjoy a sit down dinner and experience! We do recommend the pizza!

My family and I had dinner here last night and I will say the food was good, the views were great but the atmosphere was lackluster. I saw that Toast had opened up in Ocean City and we had not heard of it but were interested in trying a new "pizza" place. Upon arrival it wasn't what I expected. The outside looked beautiful by the bay but no one was sitting out there. We walked upstairs to the dinning area and saw the place was empty aside from one table outside and the small bar being filled. We were sat right away at the table of our choice. We chose a table by the window with views of the bay which I recommend. The service was impeccable by the way. I really want to get that out there. The menu is small but has a good amount of items to choose from. I was confused that the menus called Toast Waterfront Dining and Dockside Tiki Bar. Really it seems like they are searching for their identity. The food is clearly Italian and I thought Toast was inreference to the pizza but is related to toasting glasses.
We ordered 2 of the meatball appetizers, and the calamari for starters. The meatballs are fantastic with the sauce. I wish it came with a small portion of bread to soak up the sauce as that sauce is fantastic. The calamari I was less excited about. It was overcooked/fried and had a lack of flavor. I wouldn't recommend the calamari but will double down on the meatballs.
For our meals we had the cheese pizza, the Chicken Tenders with fries (for the kids) and chicken parm with side of pasta. The entrées were fantastic. The chicken parm and side pasta was fantastic. There is an option for veal and I wish I could have tried that as well. The pizza crust was very good along with the rest of the pizza. The kids liked the chicken tenders and thin shoestring fries.
To touch upon the atmosphere I wish there was some sort of theme inside the restaurant. It had a bar feel when you walked in as only people were sitting at the bar. There was also music playing but it was covers of pop music which seemed out of place for a restaurant. I saw one drawing that looked like NYC but it would be great to see more decorations related to the restaurant. I want them to embrace the pizza, embrace NYC but utilize their dockside location. The food and service was great but I wish the atmosphere matched. Takeout recommended and dining there if you are already downtown or headed to Boardwalk afterwards.